The Illusion of the Mind
“Na buddhir na ca ahamkritir naiva cittam…
(I am not the intellect, nor the ego, nor the mind…)
Having shed the heavy armor of the physical body, stripped away the delicate ties of earthly lineage, and laughed in the face of mortality, the young Shankara now stood before the most formidable fortress of all: his own mind.
The physical silence surrounding Govinda Bhagavatpada was absolute, but the inner realm Shankara was now addressing is rarely quiet. For most of humanity, the mind is a labyrinth of ceaseless noise, a chaotic bazaar of desires, memories, fears, and endless chatter. We are so intimately entwined with this inner voice that we rarely question its authority. We believe we are our thoughts. When a wave of anger arises, we say, “I am angry.” When a brilliant idea strikes, we say, “I am smart.” We surrender our identity entirely to the flickering, ever-changing weather of the mind.
But the young ascetic, his awareness now refined to a diamond-like sharpness, turned his unblinking gaze upon the thinker itself.
“Na buddhir…” I am not the intellect.
The intellect (buddhi) is the sharp, analytical instrument of human consciousness. It categorizes, judges, divides, and decides. It is the tool that built civilizations and charted the stars. Yet, Shankara realized that no matter how brilliant or refined the intellect might be, it is still merely a tool. A swordsman is not his sword, no matter how masterfully he wields it. The intellect is an object that is known and observed. There are moments when the intellect is sharp, and moments when it is dull with exhaustion. Who is it that observes this sharpness and dullness? The true Self must be the silent watcher behind the intellect, vast and unjudging.
“…na ca ahamkritir…” nor the ego.
Here, Shankara struck at the very root of human suffering. The ego (ahamkara), the “I-maker,” is the fierce, demanding gravitational center of our perceived identity. It is the voice that screams for recognition, the deeply conditioned instinct that separates “me” from “the universe.” It builds walls of pride, cowers in the shadow of insecurity, and constantly weaves a narrative in which it is the solitary hero.
With breathtaking clarity, Shankara saw the ego not as his true self, but simply as another passing thought – the “I-thought.” It is a phantom that only exists because we continuously feed it with our attention. By declaring that he was not the ego, Shankara was not forcefully destroying it; he was simply withdrawing his belief in it. He stepped back and observed the ego as one might observe a demanding child from a distance: with absolute detachment. When the “I-thought” is seen merely as an object arising in consciousness, its tyrannical power instantly evaporates.
“…naiva cittam…” nor the mind.
He negated the chitta, the vast, murky storehouse of memory, conditioning, and subconscious impressions. The mind is a relentless time-traveler, dragging us into the regrets of the past or propelling us into the anxieties of the future. It is a screen upon which the movies of our conditioning are constantly playing.
But Shankara realized he was not the movie; he was the pure, illuminating light of the projector.
If you can observe your own mind wandering – if you can watch a thought arise, linger for a moment, and then dissolve into the ether – then logically, you cannot be that thought. The observer must be entirely distinct from the observed. The true Self is the majestic, luminous presence that simply watches the mind’s turbulent weather without ever being touched by the rain.
He was unraveling the deepest knot of human illusion. He recognized that the mind is merely an instrument of perception, just like the eyes or the ears. We look through it, but we are not it. In this profound realization, the desperate need to control the mind, to quiet it by force, or to analyze its every whim simply falls away. There is no need to fight the mind when you realize you are not bound by it.
A radical freedom was blossoming. Shankara had untethered his identity from the very machinery of human thought. He was resting in pure, unadulterated awareness – a vast, spacious sanctuary untouched by the friction of intellect or the clamor of the ego.
The mind is a restless ocean of thoughts, but you are the silent depth beneath the waves, untouched by the storm at the surface.
Leave a Reply